Skip to main content

What Not to Tell a Real Estate Agent When Buying a Home

Tell your buyer’s agent what you can afford, what you need, and when you need to move. Keep raw financial records in the lender’s secure process, and agree with your agent on what they can pass to the seller. The first step is finding out who represents whom.

Two homebuyers and their agent discuss a floor plan on the sidewalk after a showing

Try our free Mortgage Calculator to calculate your calculated monthly mortgage payment before setting your search limit.

1. Find out who the agent represents

Before discussing money or timing, ask whether the person represents you, the seller, or has another role under local rules. The agent hosting a showing may be working for the seller. If you already have a buyer’s agent, ask how to route questions and offers through them.

For tours covered by National Association of Realtors practice rules, a buyer working with a covered agent generally needs a written agreement before touring. Attending an open house on your own generally does not trigger that requirement. Review services, compensation, duration, and the agent’s confidentiality obligations before you sign. Local rules and brokerage arrangements can differ. NAR guide to written buyer agreements

2. Be upfront about any buyer agreement you’ve signed

Interviewing several agents can help you decide whom to hire. Before asking a second agent to tour or write an offer, tell them about any agreement that may cover the property. Check its term, geographic scope, exclusivity, and payment obligations. Ask your current brokerage to clarify the terms if you’re unsure. NAR guide to buyer agreement terms

Working with two agents in the same market can duplicate work if both pull from the same listing database. If you’re comparing two distant markets, local expertise in each may help. Confirm that the agreements allow the arrangement and spell out which homes each agent will handle.

3. Set a search cap and authorize each offer separately

Share a search cap and a monthly housing budget with your own agent. Your lender’s approval amount, your search ceiling, and your offer authority can all be different. Include taxes, insurance, association dues, and room for upkeep when choosing your monthly target.

Suppose a lender preapproves you for a $480,000 loan, you want to see homes up to $450,000, and you authorize an opening offer of $430,000 on one house. Those are three different numbers. If you privately tell your agent you might go to $440,000 on that house, ask them to keep that figure confidential. If the seller counters, decide what to authorize next.

Try saying, “Please keep the search under $450,000. On this property, submit $430,000 and check with me before communicating any higher figure.”

4. Use the lender’s secure process for financial records

Share your financing status with your buyer’s agent and use the lender’s requested secure process for underwriting documents. Your agent can coordinate timing and confirm which documents an offer needs. Your lender can explain what you may qualify for and what they still need to verify.

A seller may ask for a preapproval letter or proof of funds for a cash offer. Ask who receives it, whether a letter or appropriately redacted statement will suffice, and what it needs to show. Confirm any redaction with the recipient. If your preapproval shows a higher figure than your offer, ask the lender whether it can issue a letter tailored to the offer. CFPB guidance on preapproval

What to share during a home search
RecipientUseful informationConfirm before sharing
Your buyer’s agentSearch cap, preferred terms, financing status, move timelineWho may see your private negotiating ceiling or reasons for moving
Mortgage lenderDocuments needed to verify income, assets, and debtsWhich upload method the lender wants you to use
Seller or listing agentAuthorized offer and relevant supporting documentsWhat supporting evidence is needed and whether a limited version is acceptable

5. Share your move deadline and keep personal details private

Give your own agent the dates they need to plan a closing. You can explain that you need keys before your lease ends without discussing a separation, a job change, or other personal circumstances. Agree on which dates or reasons can be shared with the seller.

Try saying, “I need to move by the 25th. Please ask whether the seller could close by then and keep the reason private.” If an agent uses your deadline to push you to waive an inspection or appraisal contingency, pause and ask what protection you would give up and what alternatives you have.

6. Discuss your reactions privately after a showing

Save your price discussion and candid reactions for a private conversation after the showing. Treat the house as the seller’s space. Other people may be nearby, and some properties have cameras or smart doorbells.

Your buyer’s agent still needs honest feedback. Explain which features justify a higher price to you, where you would need repairs, and which concerns would make you walk away. You can ask them to raise a specific repair question with the listing agent while keeping your enthusiasm or price ceiling private.

7. Ask your agent for advice and approve the terms yourself

Use a Zillow Zestimate as a starting point. Before basing an offer on it, ask your agent for recent comparable sales and how they accounted for differences in condition, upgrades, and location. If the online calculate and the comparable sales point in different directions, ask which facts explain the gap. How Zillow describes its Zestimate

Ask how price, credits, financing terms, contingencies, and timing could affect your offer. Use that advice to decide which terms fit your budget and how much risk you can accept.

Before submission, review the exact price, deposit, seller credits, deadlines, and documents going to the other side. Stay accurate and complete on loan applications and required disclosures. If you’re still choosing representation, use our guide to finding local real estate agents to build a shortlist.

Keep exploring Percentio

Browse the full directory to find related calculators and compare the assumptions that matter to your situation.

Browse all financial calculators →

Questions and answers

Practical answers to common planning questions.

General U.S. guidance. Check local rules and your buyer agreement.